Brantford Harlequins are back to back McCormick Cup Champions!

October 23, 2017


Brantford Harlequins are back to back McCormick Cup Champions

(MARKHAM, ON) – It was a beautiful October day this past Saturday, as Fletcher’s Fields welcomed 1200+ athletes, coaches, officials and fans to its grounds for McCormick Cup Day. On the docket for the day was the Gee Gage Cup Consolation and Final, as well as the McCormick Cup Consolation and Final. The McCormick Cup Final was the highlight of an exciting day with the Brantford Harlequins and Balmy Beach RFC taking the field to a vibrant crowd in Markham. The Brantford Harlequins came out on top of the match with a 40-27 win and were crowned the 2017 McCormick Cup Champions. In the Gee Gage Cup Final, the Toronto Scottish seconds team was crowned the 2017 champions after a 37-17 win over the Aurora Barbarians seconds.

McCormick Cup Final
The McCormick Cup Final was a dogfight from start to finish, as the defending champion Brantford Harlequins met Balmy Beach in the championship match. The two teams had fairly different seasons, with the Harlequins going undefeated, while Balmy Beach was just two games over .500. Once the ball is kicked off in the McCormick Cup Final, season records are out the window and that was evident early on.

Balmy Beach sustained early pressure in the match, which forced a Brantford penalty. This allowed Connor McCann of the Beach to slot the penalty conversion and put the initial points on the board in the match.

Brantford answered back in the 13th minute, as Graeme Mahar pounded in a try just left of the posts. Steve Piatek converted the try to bring the Quins’ early lead to 7-3. Shortly thereafter, Brantford took advantage of a Beach offside, as Piatek slotted a penalty kick to bring their lead to 10-3.

The Harlequins did not let up after padding their lead, as they continued to string together some strong phases. In the 24th minute, Hooker Eric Howard steamrolled through the Beach defense touch down on the right side of the posts. Conversion was successful from Brantford, as they brought their lead to 17-3.

Fharid Samano stepped up for the response to Brantford’s two early scores. After breaking the line, Samano found his stride and didn’t look back to score for the Beach. The try was converted by Connor McCann to bring the Beach within seven points.

Both teams were not done there, as Brantford and Balmy Beach traded tries before half time. For the Quins, Eric Howard scored his second try after a nifty one-handed catch and a sidestep. The Beach stormed back and Hank McQueen was able to punch it in. At halftime, Brantford had a narrow 22-15 lead over the Balmy Beach squad.

The second half began with a little bit of fireworks, as both teams received yellow cards after some extracurricular activities. Tom Van Horne added a try for the Brantford Harlequins shortly thereafter and Ben Harmer took a yellow card for going feet first. With a 27-15 lead, Brantford had a one-player advantage for ten minutes.

Balmy Beach did not let their shorthandedness stop them, though as Carlos Durand punched a try in after a strong set of phases. Connor McCann converted the try. Right after that, Jon West showed tremendous speed on the wing with a 50 metre run to score. With the two tries, Beach tied the match up 27-27, with 25 minutes to play.

In the 57th minute, the Brantford Harlequins took advantage of a Beach penalty to add on three points to their side. It took 14 minutes for the next scoring play, as Brantford’s Nathan Boeyenga added an insurance marker to bring their lead to 37-27. A final penalty conversion brought their lead to 40-27.

The Brantford Harlequins came away with the victory by a final score of 40-27. Though it was a 13-point deficit, the final score did not do the match any justice. The strong contingent of rugby fans were treated to an exciting rugby match at Fletcher’s Fields.

The Man of the Match for Saturday’s McCormick Cup Final was presented by Aedelhard. Paul Auzins of the Brantford Harlequins was named the Man of the Match and was awarded with a leather rugby ball and a duffle bag courtesy of Aedelhard. To see some of Aedelhard’s gear, go to

Thank you to Gilbert Rugby Canada for providing match balls for McCormick Cup Day. Go to

Tries – G. Mahar (13’), E. Howard 2 (24’, 33’), T. van Horne (45’), N. Boeyenga (70’)
Conversions – S. Piatek 3/5
Penalties – S. Piatek 3/3
Yellow – D. Shouten (42’), K. Francis (74’), S. Piatek (79’)

Tries – F. Samano (28’), H. McQueen (37’), C. Durand (48’), J. West (50’)
Conversions – C. McCann 2/4
Penalties – C. McCann 1/1
Yellow – F. Samano (42’), B. Harmer (45’), C. Hewitt (67’), C. Durand (79’)
Red – F. Samano (76’)

McCormick Cup Consolation Final
In the Consolation Final of the McCormick Cup, the Crusaders from Oakville met the Aurora Barbarians. The two teams looked to redeem themselves after early exits from the McCormick Cup playoffs. The Barbarians seemed to also have their pride on the line after a tough season which saw them suffer demotion to the Marshall Championship.

Aurora struck first in this one, taking an early 10-0 lead, but the Crusaders were resilient in their attack. They put up three straight tries to take a 26-0 lead in the second. The Aurora Barbarians were not done there though and began chipping away at Cru’s lead. The Barbs came back to hold a one point lead (27-26) at one point, but the Crusaders slotted a penalty conversion to hold on to win the match. 29-27.

Gee Gage Cup Final
In the Gee Gage Cup Final, the Toronto Scottish Seconds team met the Aurora Barbarians Seconds team. The Scottish came out with a 37-17 victory in this one and were crowned the 2017 Gee Gage Cup Champions.

Gee Gage Cup Consolation Final
Balmy Beach Seconds met the Crusaders Seconds in Gee Gage Cup Consolation play. In the morning contest, the Beach came out on top by a final score of 41-12.


The McCormick Cup is a long-standing tradition in Ontario rugby; a term synonymous with Rugby Ontario. The Cup is the title championship for Rugby Ontario's Marshall Premiership & Championship Senior Men’s First Teams, along with the annual EORU Champion.


2007 - Aurora Barbarians

2008 - Irish Canadians

2009 - Aurora Barbarians

2010 - Aurora Barbarians

2011 - Balmy Beach

2012 - Oakville Crusaders

2013 - Markham Irish

2014 - Balmy Beach

2015 - Balmy Beach

2016 - Brantford Harlequins

2017 - Brantford Harlequins


Rugby Ontario is the provincial sports governing body responsible for the organization of rugby in Ontario. Our mission is to establish a stronger identity for rugby in Ontario by promoting the sport’s core values and by fostering a culture of inclusiveness and excellence on and off the field of play.

To learn more, visit


Kevin Baxter

Communications Coordinator - Rugby Ontario

647-560-4790 x 1006


© 2022 Rugby Ontario. All Rights Reserved. Powered by SportLomo